Are Charitable Remainder Trusts a Good Idea?

For many years, the Stretch IRA was used to leave assets to heirs very tax-efficiently. Then came the SECURE Act, according to the article “Charitable Remainder Trust: The Stretch IRA Alternative” from Kiplinger. The ability for IRA beneficiaries to take the smallest of RMDs (Required Minimum Distributions) annually and leave a large sum in the IRA to grow tax-deferred over their lifetimes was over.

The SECURE Act in 2019 brought significant changes, taking away a valuable tool from anyone who died after Dec. 31, 2019. The new rules require the entire amount in an inherited IRA to be withdrawn by the end of the tenth year of the original account owner’s death. These withdrawals are taxable, so instead of stretching the withdrawal out over an extended period, accounts must be emptied, and taxes paid within a relatively short period. Compared to the stretch, the Ten-Year Rule is, in a word, taxing. It's crucial to understand these changes and their implications.

There are exceptions to the rule for certain beneficiaries, including spouses and disabled individuals, non-spouse beneficiaries no more than ten years younger than the original account owner and a biological or adopted minor until they reach age 21. On their 21^st birthday, they have ten years to empty the account.

There are alternative strategies for IRA owners to consider to help heirs enjoy more of their legacy, which an experienced estate planning attorney will know. One is the Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT), which offers both tax benefits and charitable giving.

Start by designating a CRT as the beneficiary of your IRA. When you die, the assets will pass to the CRT. Since the CRT is a tax-exempt entity, the assets in the IRA continue to grow tax deferred. The CRT’s beneficiaries receive income distributions over a specified period. At the end of the CRT, any remaining funds go to a charitable beneficiary.

CRT beneficiaries may receive distributions over a much longer period than a direct inheritance or inherited IRA, which has a mandated 10-year distribution.

The CRT strategy is best for charitably minded people who would have donated to the charity regardless of the IRA restrictions. If this aligns with your values, it makes sense from an estate planning perspective. There are costs associated with setting up a CRT, which should be considered when considering the totality of your estate plan. Speak with your estate planning attorney to see if this makes sense for you and your family.

Reference: Kiplinger (April 19, 2024) “Charitable Remainder Trust: The Stretch IRA Alternative”