
If a lender wants your personal guarantee or a claim has already been made, timing decides what you can protect: in Louisiana, a transfer made after a creditor’s right arises can be undone. Wealth Planning Law Group is a New Orleans law firm handling estate planning, tax, asset protection and business succession for owners of operating businesses in Louisiana and across the country. Todd M. Villarrubia is Board Certified in Estate Planning & Administration by the Louisiana Board of Legal Specialization, holds an LL.M. in Taxation from Emory University, and has more than 30 years of experience.
The four situations below look different, but they turn on the same point. A physician after a claim, a landlord whose tenant has sued, an owner with a dozen units in a patchwork of LLCs, and a borrower facing a personal guarantee are each asking what a creditor can reach and whether anything can still be done about it. The answer depends on whether the planning came before the claim or after it.
Before a claim exists, you have real choices: how your properties and businesses are divided among entities, how assets are titled, what insurance sits in front of them, and what the terms of a guarantee say. After a claim, those choices narrow, and one Louisiana rule explains why.
The rule is the revocatory action. Under Louisiana Civil Code article 2036, a creditor can ask a court to annul an act of the debtor, made after the creditor’s right arose, that causes or increases the debtor’s insolvency. Two more articles set the standard for different kinds of transfers:
The creditor’s side of the revocatory action has a deadline. Under article 2041, the action must be brought within one year from the time the creditor learned or should have learned of the act, and never after three years from the date of the act. Those limits are the creditor’s deadline to sue, not a grace period for the debtor: until the window closes, a transfer stays open to challenge.
Two things follow. A transfer made after a creditor’s right has arisen is the kind of transfer the revocatory action exists to reach, so moving assets in response to a claim can undo the protection instead of creating it. And the article looks to when the creditor’s right arose, not to the day a lawsuit was filed, so whether a particular transfer was too late is a legal question to settle with a lawyer before anything is retitled.
That is why the planning that stays inside the law is prospective. Lawful, prospective planning arranges how assets are held before a claim exists or a guarantee is signed. Planning that starts after a creditor’s right has arisen is no longer prospective, and it runs into the rule above. That limits what you can do about the claim you already have. It doesn’t stop you from planning for the next one. A demand letter, a pending suit or a signed guarantee is often what gets the planning started, and the planning can still be lawful, as long as each step is checked against the claim that already exists.
If you’re in Covington or elsewhere on the North Shore, or in Jefferson Parish, and a lender wants your personal guarantee on a loan to your company, the guarantee changes what your LLC does for you. An LLC generally separates your personal assets from the company’s debts. A personal guarantee is your own promise to pay, so for that loan the separation does not apply.
The time to plan is before you sign. From the day a guarantee is signed, the lender is a creditor of yours, and assets moved afterward fall into the revocatory action analysis above. Before signing, find out what the guarantee covers (this loan only, or every debt the company owes the lender), whether it is capped in amount or in time, and what you own that the lender could reach if the company defaulted. Those are questions to answer with your lawyer while the terms can still be negotiated. If you have already signed, the lender is already your creditor on that debt. Planning can still separate future business risk from your family’s assets, but each step has to be checked against the guarantees you have signed.
If you practice in Slidell or elsewhere on the North Shore and a patient has sent a demand letter or filed a claim, your malpractice coverage answers it first. What matters for planning is anything that could exceed that coverage and reach your personal assets.
Start with what Louisiana law already protects. Under Louisiana’s exemption statutes, qualified retirement accounts are exempt from seizure to the extent they are tax-exempt, though contributions made less than a year before a seizure or bankruptcy filing are not. Under La. R.S. 22:912, life insurance proceeds and cash value are exempt from the insured’s debts, except that cash value above $35,000 is not protected for a policy issued within nine months before a seizure or bankruptcy filing. Louisiana also exempts up to $35,000 in value of an owner-occupied homestead from seizure under La. R.S. 20:1, subject to exceptions for certain debts, such as taxes and certain mortgages and loans. Above those amounts, how your assets are held, in entities, trusts and policies, determines what a creditor can reach. Knowing what is already out of reach comes before deciding whether anything else needs to move.
What you should not do is move assets to a spouse, a child or a trust once a claim exists, without advice. A gift made at that point is the kind of transfer article 2039 allows a creditor to attack, and the person who receives it does not have to have known about the claim.
If you own rental property in Mandeville and a tenant has sued, the suit is against the entity that owns the property, or against you personally if you own it in your own name. Property held in your own name has no separation at all. Property held in one LLC along with other properties exposes all of them to a claim arising at any one of them.
The LLC also does not protect you from your own conduct. A claim that rests on what you personally did or failed to do can reach you whatever entity owns the building. And once the suit exists, restructuring runs into the revocatory action: moving the property into a new entity after the right arose is a transfer a creditor can challenge.
The planning that works comes before any claim: one property per entity where that makes sense, insurance sized to the property, and leases, bank accounts and expenses kept with the entity that owns the building. Read the mortgage and the insurance policy before retitling a property, because either may require the lender’s or insurer’s consent.
If you’re in Metairie and your twelve units are spread across several LLCs that were formed one at a time, the question is whether the entities actually separate the properties. Look at which entity holds title to each building, which one signs the leases, which one pays the expenses, and whether any properties sit together in the same entity. A structure that grew one purchase at a time should be looked at as a whole, because properties sharing an entity share its exposure.
Fixing it means deciding which properties belong together, which should stand alone, and how ownership of the entities themselves is held. Those changes are best made while no claim exists. If a lawsuit is what exposed the gaps, the restructuring can still go ahead for the properties and claims going forward, but each change has to be checked against the pending suit first. How the entities are owned also has to fit your estate plan, because that decides who holds them after you. Our page on trust vs. LLC protection for business owners explains how the two tools work together, and our asset protection video series walks through how we approach the planning.
Choose a lawyer on three criteria, and ask for each one by name.
Todd M. Villarrubia meets each of these. He is Board Certified in Estate Planning & Administration by the Louisiana Board of Legal Specialization, holds an LL.M. in Taxation from Emory University, and reviews the business, the trusts and the insurance strategy as one plan together with your estate plan.
Whichever situation is yours, the order is the same: find out what is exposed, find out what Louisiana law already protects, fix what can be fixed before a claim or a signature, and pay attention to the tax consequences of every transfer. Retitling property or moving it into a trust or entity can carry gift tax reporting and can change the cost basis your heirs receive, so the asset protection plan and the tax plan have to be built together.
With Todd M. Villarrubia, the tax answer and the trust document come from the same desk.
It is the action a creditor can bring under Louisiana Civil Code article 2036 to annul an act of the debtor, made after the creditor’s right arose, that causes or increases the debtor’s insolvency. Under article 2041, the creditor must bring it within one year from the time the creditor learned or should have learned of the act, and never after three years from the date of the act. It is why asset protection planning has to happen before a claim, a lawsuit or a signed guarantee, not after.
Not safely without advice. A creditor can attack a gift made after the creditor’s right arose, whether or not the person who received it knew it would cause or increase your insolvency, and a creditor can annul a sale or other exchange if the other party knew or should have known it would do so. Talk to a lawyer before retitling anything.
No. An LLC generally separates your personal assets from the company’s debts, but a personal guarantee is your own promise to pay. For that loan, the lender can look to you directly. The time to plan is before you sign.
Separate entities are what keep a claim at one property from reaching the others, and the protection depends on the separation being real. It does not cover a claim based on your own conduct, and it does not cover a debt you have personally guaranteed.
What the guarantee covers (one loan or every debt the company owes the lender), whether it is capped in amount or in time, and what you own that the lender could reach if the company defaulted. Review those with your lawyer before you sign, while the terms can still be negotiated.
101 W. Allen Toussaint Blvd., Suite 404
New Orleans, LA 70124
Phone: (504) 900-2763
Email: todd@lawealthplan.com
